1131 Pleasant Street, Indianapolis, IN 46203
sale
$350,000
|
Other
Courtesy Of Carpenter Realtors
Do you hear that bellowing? That's the cash cow of 1129-1131 Pleasant St, calling out to its new owner! This 6-unit apartment building is tucked back off Shelby St, on a quiet street, in the shade of mature hardwoods, in the heart of Fountain Square, & is plum full of satisfied tenants who wish to stay right where they are, even through a transition in ownership. Generating $5100/mo in rental revenue (maybe more, as present rents are somewhat below FMV), the building features 2 spacious main-floor apartments (one w/ 2 BRs, and 1 w/ 1BR + a bonus room), as well as four 1BR efficiency apartments upstairs. This building looks good, lives easily, rents well & will make a NICE addition to any urban Indy portfolio. While the county records say the building was built in 1965, we suspect it was actually *converted* to multi-family in 1965, for many of its architectural features reflect a historic era, including the covered front porch, the fireplace mantels, traces of craftsman woodwork t/o & the soaring ceiling heights. The building has enjoyed many updates under the current ownership, including a new heat pump in 2019, many new windows (2020-2023) + various structural, mechanical & cosmetic updates to all the apartments in recent years. Behind the building is a large green space w/ an alley-load parking lot, and street-parking in the front is abundant & available for all. 5 of the 6 units are presently leased, the 6th has several applications in review right now. If you are going to check out this opportunity, note the local amenities nearby that make this building so appealing, such as public transportation & shops/restaurants/parks/employment w/in walking distance. DO NOT DISTURB THE TENANTS! **Reported size of the building & the apartments is approximate. Marion County says the building is 2156sf, but it looks & feels larger than that**
Read More About This Property
Read Less About This Property
Copyright © 2026 MIBOR Service Corporation. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. Information being provided is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
Property Features
- Age: Over 50 Years Old
- Architecture Style: Other
- Building Units: 6
- Cooling System: Window Unit(s)
- Cooling System: Multi Units
- Cooling System: Heat Pump
- Exterior Type: Vinyl Siding
- Heating System: Heat Pump (Heating)
- Heating System: Forced Air
- Heating System: Zoned (Heating)
- Heating System: Natural Gas
- Legal Description: Fletchers Woodlawn Add L30
- MLSID: 22070674
- Roof Type: Asphalt
- Rooms: Basement
Data powered by Attom Data Solutions. Copyright© 2025. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
You may also be interested in...
sale
$425,000
Mixed Use
839 S Lynhurst Drive
Indianapolis, IN 46241
Building: 2,156 sq. ft.
|
Land: 0.36 Acres
Courtesy Of Armstrong Real Estate Brokerage
sale
$400,000
Mixed Use
4240 & 4244 Madison Avenue
Indianapolis, IN 46227
Building: 3,186 sq. ft.
|
Land: 0.95 Acres
Courtesy Of Jeff Paxson Team
sale
$400,000
Mixed Use
3363 Central Avenue
Indianapolis, IN 46205
Building: 6,720 sq. ft.
|
Land: 0.27 Acres
Courtesy Of Keller Williams Indianapolis Metro North
sale
$400,000
Office
1655 W County Line Road
Greenwood, IN 46142
Land: 0.89 Acres
Courtesy Of Highgarden Real Estate